Saraswati or Indus Valley Civilization?

Saraswati River

India is the cradle of the human race, the birthplace of human speech, the mother of history, the grandmother of legend, and the great grand mother of tradition.(Mark Twain).

I haven’t been able to write since last one week, the reason,pre-occuppied with reading and analysing the read with reference to river Saraswati.

The river was evoked as an auspicious river as well as the deity of knowledge.Our parents and grandparents have always referred to it as goddess and a spiritual river on the banks of which Rig Vedas was written.As a kid though I was fascinated by the mythological tales, however would always trust my text books for information.

Unfortunately the time I completed my school education, could not find any reference of Saraswati  in the NCERT syllabus nor was there much to read on Harappa. So, here I was believing firmly in the early British Raj discoverer’s of the Ancient India times.We need to thank those archaeologists ,like Max Muller to have helped us give a window to our past,but as was the times, the way those discoveries were presented it gave us a totally different picture of how our past was. It did help us come out from a thousand year slumber, but with that also came British raj’s own interpretations and the way those things needed to be taught to the public.(Maculley education system).

Saraswati river was once only talked about in our mythology stories and in Rig Veda,but now it is apparent from Satelllite images that there was a river flowing in the region which is now Rajasthan/Bikaner all the way to runn of Katch.

One section of study stays, that Harappan culture was formed initially within the Sarswati region as per the excavated sites of Kalibangan and Dholavira and couple of them in Haryana.Slowly it expanded towards Indus, with sites like Mohenjodaro, developing on its own.harappan symbols

We were told about Harappan civilization, but then it was highlighted as one of little consequence to modern India.When the excavations were done, though ideally we should have marveled at our ancestors achievements, but then we were left with more questions than answers.

When I read about this civilization,I have to admit that Harrapan was the most advanced civilization of its time.More advanced and mature than the ones in Egypt and Mesopotamia.

Couple of points would like to highlight:

Harappans traded with Sumerians(Mesopotamians) and countries like modern day Oman,Harappan porcelean beads and other forms of pottery are found with them,however there is no evidence of Harappans getting anything back from Mesopotamians, Egyptians,central Asian people or people from Oxus valley.( Harrapans -Saraswati valley people were great exporters).

Harappans originated the decimal system, geometry,pythagoras theorem(Pythagoras was Greek).

Remember that song from Mr.Bharat Movie

Harappans were non violent people,archaeologists could not find any weapons or swords,apart from couple of spears which probably were used by gate keepers of the town.

Harappans did not have any King,there was equality, though there were rich people but all in all state took good care of every one.Rich people were living next to modest homes.

Harappans-Saraswati people did not build monuments like Pyramids for ruling class,but built great cities, with amazing buildings, they had made bath rooms on the first floor of a 3 floor structure.

Rigveda was written during  Saraswati- Harappan times,with Yoga, Shiva as the symbols found from the excavations of Harappan sites.

Harappan were perfect in calculations, the streets and dimensions of lanes which Harappans took, similar ratios were taken a thousand year later in the early half of BC.(This shows that Harappans were very advanced and also that their system of measurement was in practice even during the so called Aryan times).

Harappan girl image

Harappan girl image

The dancing girl statue recovered from Harappa has similar kind of ornaments being worn by Rajasthani women even today.

The measurements used by Kautilya(Chanakya) in Arthashastra are described exactly similar to Harappan times and so was the weight system.

While reading, I also realised that Aryan Invasion theory is seriously in question now,with arrival of Aryans being proved by nothing.Disappearance of Harappan cities cannot be attributed to an invasion.We haven’t found any dead bodies no armour,absolutely no evidence of mass destruction or killing,In fact according to Michel Danino there has been no invasion.It is because of the drying up of Saraswati river that civilization moved eastwards towards Gangetic plain!

But you know, there are divergent views depending on the school of thought.I hope we all get to read about the common agreed thought sometime soon and the language used by Harappans gets deciphered as well.

But what we see today, of the country, we find it difficult to say that our land had the most advanced civilization of its times.Our modern day civic sense absolutely gives away,the so called cultural heritage.



University of Chicago Lecture :Meluhha The Indus valley

 michel Danino


Posted in Indus Valley & Harappan Civilization and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , by with 10 comments.


  • Mridul says:

    Nice read article. can you put the source of ‘symbol image’

  • murali says:

    This concept also forms the basis for the plot of the novel ‘The Krishna Key’ by Ashwin Sanghi. He further argues that when the river dried up, the people on west coast of Saraswati migrated to Indus and further to Euphrates-Tigris while those on the east settled in the Gangetic plains.

    • rahul says:

      Hi Murli,you might be correct.Though, I haven’t read his book, Krishna Key.
      This author(Michel Danino) and the video of Chicago University does reflect that Harrapans, probably established small factories in Mesopotamian port cities,apart from exporting goods.So,may be those trading posts could have influenced the Sumerian culture.Yes,the writer also corroborates with evidence,that people did move from Saraswati to Gangetic plain and towards Sindh & Baluchistan.

  • 0rTZ says:

    727797 320394quite good post, i surely genuinely like this remarkable internet site, maintain on it 427143

  • Hong says:

    Where did you get your sources for this?

  • Thanks for finally talking about > Saraswati or
    Indus Valley Civilization | History Unravelled < Loved it!

  • Hello there! This article could not be written much better!
    Looking through this post reminds me of my previous roommate!
    He continually kept talking about this. I’ll send this article to
    him. Fairly certain he’s going to have a good read.
    Many thanks for sharing!

  • admin says:

    thank you for your encouraging comments. appreciate them

Pingbacks & Trackbacks

  • Canada Goose sale

    I admire the useful information you offer in your articles or blog posts. I will bookmark your blog and have my youngsters examine up here often. Im quite sure they will discover a lot of new things here than anyone else!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

%d bloggers like this: